Behavioural Finance in the Era of Coronavirus

17/04/2020
Behavioural Finance in the era of coronavirus

Summary

No doubt about it, the reaction of the capital markets to the spread of the coronavirus has been dramatic. The “VIX” Index (rightfully referred to as the “Fear Index”), which measures fluctuations in prices (“volatility”) on the US stock market, has reached a record level of 80, even exceeding its peak during the financial crisis. The US equity market recorded its greatest one-day loss in 30 years.

Key takeaways

  • Rationalize to prevent overreactions.
  • Get to know yourself - and then outsmart yourself!
  • Think about the strategic allocation for your investments now.
  • Also include sustainable aspects in your considerations.

The virus is spreading, yet at the same time monetary policy and fiscal countermeasures are being introduced worldwide, so it is advisable for us, as investors, to be self-aware in order to be ready with a carefully considered response. To help, we have put together some thoughts based on behavioural finance, because fear and panic are usually the  
worst advisers.

Human, all too human

To be afraid is human, all too human. The next level is panic. The Duden dictionary defines panic as “an overwhelming fear provoked by a sudden threat or danger, which paralyses one’s ability to think and leads one to react recklessly”. To escape from the danger zone, we must recognise the danger – but without allowing it to control us. We have to think rationally. And this is precisely where behavioural finance can help. You see, it’s all about our brain – specifically, the most important parts of the brain, and how they interact.

In his book “Thinking fast and Slow”, Richard Kahneman (who along with Amos Tversky is considered one of the fathers of behavioural finance) essentially drew a distinction between two large areas of the brain that have very different functions, pointing out that we cannot know which part of the brain is working at any given point in time. One part of the brain, the so-called limbic system, is very fast, very emotional. This is where the so-called “gut feeling” originates. The other part of the brain, the so-called neocortex, is slower and is in charge of our rational thinking, or careful reasoning. To be exact, we should also include the brain stem. Evolutionarily, it is the oldest part of our brain. This is where the fear centre is located. 

The structure of our brain follows evolutionary logic: in the early history of human evolution, those traits that were required for survival were also the ones that developed first. Our ancestors needed to perceive risk and to flee from dangerous situations as quickly as possible. The need for logic arose much later.

As a result, during a crisis, the fear centre is the first to spring into action. When it detects danger, the limbic system takes over and reacts rapidly and instinctively. To do so, it relies on behavioural patterns to escape from the danger zone, without any conscious reasoning. While even today it is important for us to rely on our intuition, it is just as important for us to understand and recognise these processes. But it is also important for us to think rationally in order to avoid overreacting. 

Know thyself

If you want to avoid overreacting, you have to be self-aware: why do I react the way I do? What motivates me to take certain actions, for example, regarding investments? What are the effects of the behavioural anomalies, seen in every human, that have been carefully studied by scientists? 

To drill deeper into behavioural finance, here is our white paper “Outsmart yourself”.

Loss aversion


The best-known behavioural anomaly, whose discovery can be regarded as the birth of behavioural finance, is probably loss aversion. This refers to the fact that the pain we feel from one unit of loss is greater than the pleasure we derive from one unit of gain. In other words: we will be more upset over losing Euro 100 than we will be thrilled about a Euro 100 profit. Accordingly, we place greater weight on the current losses in the capital markets than on previous gains, some of which may have accrued over many years.

A small window on the big world of investments

Another important anomaly is the so-called “framing effect”. We create a frame through which we observe the world (of investments). It functions as a news filter. In the current situation, we focus on all the negative news about the coronavirus – but do we also take into account the countermeasures that have already been taken and/or are still likely to be taken? 

In fact, a great deal is currently being done, both in terms of monetary and fiscal policy, and we can expect more to be done in the future. Some of these measures even exceed those adopted during the 2008-09 financial crisis. As of mid-March, more than 30 central banks have lowered their benchmark interest rates. The European Central Bank (ECB) has launched a new Euro 750 billion bond-purchase programme. In order to restore stability and, above all, confidence among investors and/or companies, and to mitigate the negative impact on companies and the economy, numerous governments around the world have also announced fiscal packages, some of them quite massive. The US alone is considering an economic rescue package in excess of U.S. Dollar 1 trillion. In addition to tax deferrals, the focus is mainly on guarantees for corporate loans, which amount to 12% of GDP in France and 15% in the UK. 

Are investors aware of this, or are these efforts being ignored due to the “framing effect”?

Behavioural-Finance-Figure1-en

At the same time, the “framing effect” deceives people into focusing much more on current trends. Looking ahead, the real question should be: what can we expect in the future? When is a recovery likely? 

 

Outsmarting yourself

These findings from behavioural finance suggest some rules of conduct for the present. One thing seems certain already: if central banks around the world flood the markets with liquidity and resume purchases of government bonds in even greater quantities, the low-interest/negative-interest environment can be expected to persist even longer and to expand. In the US, negative Treasury yields appeared for the first time in mid-March 2020. For investors seeking returns, this will only exacerbate the problem. 

So, from the standpoint of behavioural finance, what can investors do to avoid being caught on the wrong foot while at the same time not missing the right time to buy? 

In my view, the Odysseus Strategy always turns out to be the best strategy: it involves “tying oneself to the mast” in order to achieve one’s goals. Like the hero in the Greek epic, who has himself tied to the mast to avoid succumbing to the Sirens’ song, investors also need to commit to a strategy that will help them to stay on track.

This raises the following questions:

  • How much risk can I tolerate?
  • How much can I stand to lose?
  • What level of profit do I expect, and over what time horizon
  • What are my expectations for the future?

In short, this is the right time to be thinking about strategic asset allocation. A tip: think holistically, ie, not just about financial assets, but instead all assets – real estate, insurance, pension, and even your own work, as these all produce an income stream. 

Devil’s advocate

It’s important to have a devil’s advocate – someone to discuss your thoughts with you, question them and help you to enlarge the frame through which you observe the world. You should also look specifically for trustworthy information and analyses that go beyond the mainstream and beyond the daily news. 

Many investors also find it useful to enshrine their commitment in a small “contract”. The devil’s advocate could be your foil, in which case the contractual commitment might read as follows: Remind me of my plans and help me to keep my eye on my goals, before I act too hastily. Challenge my plans, which may be based on emotion.

Active is: Turning strategy into reality

Once you’ve determined your strategic asset allocation, you need to implement it. So-called “multi asset” investments can help here. These are portfolios that can invest across all asset classes in an effort to minimise portfolio volatility and make tactical adjustments, ie, to react to the market trend.

Where greater amounts of money are waiting to be (re-) invested, why not devise a big savings plan? Starting on a specific date, make additional purchases over several quarters in order to reach the desired asset structure. That will smooth out fluctuations and help you avoid betting everything on the right horse at the wrong time.

And, of course, it’s always the right time to launch a “small” savings plan, which you can do with just a few Euro per month.

Don’t miss our white paper “Using the 7 habits of successful investors”.
 

Behavioural-Finance-Figure2-en

To conclude, I have this tip for you: start thinking about  the sustainability of your investments, as well. You can achieve sustainability by applying EGS (environmental, social and governance) criteria as filters when making  your investment decisions. 

Good luck tying yourself to the mast  
(your self-commitment) – and stay healthy.

 

> download

 

Being a rational optimist

20/04/2020
rational optimist

Summary

The world is becoming a better place. All the indicators concur: increasing life expectancy on every continent of the planet, falling child mortality and child labor, rising prosperity and, from a global perspective, declining inequality. Wherever the forces of creative disruption are allowed to unfold, we have every reason to be rational optimists. But what does this mean for investors and others?

Allianz Global Investors

You are leaving this website and being re-directed to the below website. This does not imply any approval or endorsement of the information by Allianz Global Investors Asia Pacific Limited contained in the redirected website nor does Allianz Global Investors Asia Pacific Limited accept any responsibility or liability in connection with this hyperlink and the information contained herein. Please keep in mind that the redirected website may contain funds and strategies not authorized for offering to the public in your jurisdiction. Besides, please also take note on the redirected website’s terms and conditions, privacy and security policies, or other legal information. By clicking “Continue”, you confirm you acknowledge the details mentioned above and would like to continue accessing the redirected website. Please click “Stay here” if you have any concerns.

Welcome to Allianz Global Investors

Select your language
  • 中文(繁體)
  • English
Select your role
  • Individual Investor
  • Intermediaries
  • Other Investors
  • Pension Investors
  • Allianz Global Investors Fund (“AGIF”)

    • Allianz Global Investors Fund (“AGIF”) as an umbrella fund under the UCITS regulations has within it different sub-funds investing in fixed income securities, equities, and derivative instruments, each with a different investment objective and/or risk profile.

    • All sub-funds (“Sub-Funds”) may invest in financial derivative instruments (“FDI”) which may expose to higher leverage, counterparty, liquidity, valuation, volatility, market and over the counter transaction risks. A Sub-Fund’s net derivative exposure may be up to 50% of its NAV. 

    • Some Sub-Funds as part of their investments may invest in any one or a combination of the instruments such as fixed income securities, emerging market securities, and/or mortgage-backed securities, asset-backed securities, property-backed securities (especially REITs) and/or structured products and/or FDI, exposing to various potential risks (including leverage, counterparty, liquidity, valuation, volatility, market, fluctuations in the value of and the rental income received in respect of the underlying property, and over the counter transaction risks). 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in single countries or industry sectors (in particular small/mid cap companies) which may reduce risk diversification. Some Sub-Funds are exposed to significant risks which include investment/general market, country and region, emerging market (such as Mainland China), creditworthiness/credit rating/downgrading, default, asset allocation, interest rate, volatility and liquidity, counterparty, sovereign debt, valuation, credit rating agency, company-specific, currency  (in particular RMB), RMB debt securities and Mainland China tax risks. 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in convertible bonds, high-yield, non-investment grade investments and unrated securities that may subject to higher risks (include volatility, loss of principal and interest, creditworthiness and downgrading, default, interest rate, general market and liquidity risks) and therefore may adversely impact the net asset value of the Sub-Funds. Convertibles will be exposed prepayment risk, equity movement and greater volatility than straight bond investments.

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest a significant portion of the assets in interest-bearing securities issued or guaranteed by a non-investment grade sovereign issuer (e.g. Philippines) and is subject to higher risks of liquidity, credit, concentration and default of the sovereign issuer as well as greater volatility and higher risk profile that may result in significant losses to the investors. 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in European countries. The economic and financial difficulties in Europe may get worse and adversely affect the Sub-Funds (such as increased volatility, liquidity and currency risks associated with investments in Europe).

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in the China A-Shares market, China B-Shares market and/or debt securities directly  via the Stock Connect or the China Interbank Bond Market or Bond Connect and or other foreign access regimes and/or other permitted means and/or indirectly through all eligible instruments the qualified foreign institutional investor program regime and thus is subject to the associated risks (including quota limitations, change in rule and regulations, repatriation of the Fund’s monies, trade restrictions, clearing and settlement, China market volatility and uncertainty, China market volatility and uncertainty, potential clearing and/or settlement difficulties and, change in economic, social and political policy in the PRC and taxation Mainland China tax risks).  Investing in RMB share classes is also exposed to RMB currency risks and adverse impact on the share classes due to currency depreciation.

    • Some Sub-Funds may adopt the following strategies, Sustainable and Responsible Investment Strategy, SDG-Aligned Strategy, Sustainability Key Performance Indicator Strategy (Relative), Green Bond Strategy, Multi Asset Sustainable Strategy, Sustainability Key Performance Indicator Strategy (Absolute Threshold), Environment, Social and Governance (“ESG”) Score Strategy, and Sustainability Key Performance Indicator Strategy (Absolute). The Sub-Funds may be exposed to sustainable investment risks relating to the strategies (such as foregoing opportunities to buy certain securities when it might otherwise be advantageous to do so, selling securities when it might be disadvantageous to do so, and/or relying on information and data from third party ESG research data providers and internal analyses which may be subjective, incomplete, inaccurate or unavailable and/or reducing risk diversifications compared to broadly based funds) which may result in the Sub-Fund being more volatile and have adverse impact on the performance of the Sub-Fund and consequently adversely affect an investor’s investment in the Sub-Fund. Also, some Sub-Funds may be particularly focusing on the GHG efficiency of the investee companies rather than their financial performance which may have an adverse impact on the Fund’s performance.

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in share class with fixed distribution percentage (Class AMf). Investors should note that fixed distribution percentage is not guaranteed. The share class is not an alternative to fixed interest paying investment. The percentage of distributions paid by these share classes is unrelated to expected or past income or returns of these share classes or the Sub-Funds. Distribution will continue even the Sub-Fund has negative returns and may adversely impact the net asset value of the Sub-Fund.  Positive distribution yield does not imply positive return.

    • Investment involves risks that could result in loss of part or entire amount of investors’ investment.

    • In making investment decisions, investors should not rely solely on this [website/material].

    Note: Dividend payments may, at the sole discretion of the Investment Manager, be made out of the Sub-Fund’s capital or effectively out of the Sub-Fund’s capital which represents a return or withdrawal of part of the amount investors originally invested and/or capital gains attributable to the original investment. This may result in an immediate decrease in the NAV per share and the capital of the Sub-Fund available for investment in the future and capital growth may be reduced, in particular for hedged share classes for which the distribution amount and NAV of any hedged share classes (HSC) may be adversely affected by differences in the interests rates of the reference currency of the HSC and the base currency of the respective Sub-Fund. Dividend payments are applicable for Class A/AM/AMg/AMi/AMgi/AQ Dis (Annually/Monthly/Quarterly distribution) and for reference only but not guaranteed.  Positive distribution yield does not imply positive return. For details, please refer to the Sub-Fund’s distribution policy disclosed in the offering documents.


    Allianz Global Investors Asia Fund

    • Allianz Global Investors Asia Fund (the “Trust”) is an umbrella unit trust constituted under the laws of Hong Kong pursuant to the Trust Deed. Allianz Thematic Income and Allianz Selection Income and Growth and Allianz Yield Plus Fund are the sub-funds of the Trust (each a “Sub-Fund”) investing in fixed income securities, equities and derivative instrument, each with a different investment objective and/or risk profile.

    • Some Sub-Funds are exposed to significant risks which include investment/general market, company-specific, emerging market, creditworthiness/credit rating/downgrading, default, volatility and liquidity, valuation, sovereign debt, thematic concentration, thematic-based investment strategy, counterparty, interest rate changes, country and region, asset allocation risks and currency (such as exchange controls, in particular RMB), and the adverse impact on RMB share classes due to currency depreciation.  

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in other underlying collective schemes and exchange traded funds. Investing in exchange traded funds may expose to additional risks such as passive investment, tracking error, underlying index, trading and termination. While investing in other underlying collective schemes (“CIS”) may subject to the risks associated to such CIS. 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in high-yield (non-investment grade and unrated) investments and/or convertible bonds which may subject to higher risks, such as volatility, creditworthiness, default, interest rate changes, general market and liquidity risks and therefore may  adversely impact the net asset value of the Fund. Convertibles may also expose to risks such as prepayment, equity movement, and greater volatility than straight bond investments.

    • All Sub-Funds may invest in financial derivative instruments (“FDI”) which may expose to higher leverage, counterparty, liquidity, valuation, volatility, market and over the counter transaction risks.  The use of derivatives may result in losses to the Sub-Funds which are greater than the amount originally invested. A Sub-Fund’s net derivative exposure may be up to 50% of its NAV.

    • These investments may involve risks that could result in loss of part or entire amount of investors’ investment.

    • In making investment decisions, investors should not rely solely on this website.

    Note: Dividend payments may, at the sole discretion of the Investment Manager, be made out of the Sub-Fund’s income and/or capital which in the latter case represents a return or withdrawal of part of the amount investors originally invested and/or capital gains attributable to the original investment. This may result in an immediate decrease in the NAV per distribution unit and the capital of the Sub-Fund available for investment in the future and capital growth may be reduced, in particular for hedged share classes for which the distribution amount and NAV of any hedged share classes (HSC) may be adversely affected by differences in the interests rates of the reference currency of the HSC and the base currency of the Sub-Fund. Dividend payments are applicable for Class A/AM/AMg/AMi/AMgi Dis (Annually/Monthly distribution) and for reference only but not guaranteed.  Positive distribution yield does not imply positive return. For details, please refer to the Sub-Fund’s distribution policy disclosed in the offering documents.

     

Please indicate you have read and understood the Important Notice.