A growth slowdown could change the course of the 2020 US elections

19/02/2020
AllianzGI-US-economy-in-lead-up-to-election

Summary

The US economy’s current good health is good news for President Donald Trump ahead of his bid for re-election later this year, but there is scope for market volatility – and even an economic deterioration – before November’s poll

Key takeaways

  • The US economy is strong, but the boost from the 2017 fiscal stimulus is fading and trade uncertainty is still high – potentially slowing the economy during the 2020 election season.
  • Since 1948, only three incumbent presidents have lost their re-election bids, and all faced economic challenges during the run-up to election day.
  • No president in modern US history has run for re-election with unemployment as low as President Trump enjoys today.
  • Investors should expect trade – and election-related – volatility to accelerate in 2020, broadening potential for risk and reward and the need for active management.

The 2020 US elections on 3 November will help determine the outlook for investors for years to come. Yet rather than try to predict who will win, we think investors should focus on economic issues in the coming months – concentrating on the environment we might expect and the factors affecting it, particularly fiscal stimulus and trade policy. 

The presidential race is the most significant of 2020 

Since the state of the economy has historically played a large role in how Americans vote in presidential elections, now is a good time to assess the outlook for growth and how it compares to past cycles. Right now, the US economy appears to be in decent shape – which is good news for President Donald Trump. Unemployment is at the lowest level since 1969 and GDP growth probably averaged about 2.3% in 2019. That’s faster than America’s long-run potential GDP growth rate of around 1.9%, although it’s a downshift from 2.9% in 2018.

The big question is whether this environment will last until the elections. Will unemployment remain historically low, will growth decelerate further and, if so, is there risk of recession? 

History shows that a strong economy makes it much easier for a president to get re-elected

Our research shows that since 1948, incumbent US presidents have typically been re-elected – but not if the economy performs poorly leading up to the vote, and never during recession. In fact, over the last 71 years, only three incumbent presidents have lost re-election bids—Gerald Ford (1976), Jimmy Carter (1980) and George H.W. Bush (1992). All three battled tough economic conditions during their campaigns:

  • Losing incumbents saw unemployment trend higher as their re-election contests progressed – moving from an average of 7.1% at the start of the ballot year to 7.5%during the vote. Conversely, every winning incumbent except President Dwight Eisenhower benefited from a strengthening job market, with unemployment falling from an average of 6.2% to 5.9% (see chart).
  • Importantly, for losing incumbents, economic growth was markedly weaker during the months leading up
    to and immediately following the election, averaging 2.2% from April-December versus 4.0% for the winners. And growth wasn’t just weaker; it slowed heading into November for Presidents Ford and Bush. President Carter was particularly unlucky, fighting outright economic contraction as Americans went to the polls.
  • Similar trends exist in other key data. For instance, consumer sentiment was significantly higher for winning incumbents than it was for those who lost, and employers hired workers at an accelerating pace as the winning incumbents were up for re-election.
  • One anomaly: S&P 500 performance has not been a good election predictor. Losing incumbents generally campaigned during stronger equity markets than winners.

US-economy-in-lead-up-to-elections-HK-en-chart1

The effects of Mr. Trump’s 2017 tax stimulus are fading

No US president in modern history has campaigned in an environment with unemployment as low as it is today at 3.5%. If this continues, it will almost certainly help President Trump’s chances. 

But the election-year trend is also important, and some estimates show that by the fourth quarter of 2020, GDP growth could slow to 1.7% – below potential – while unemployment could edge up to 3.7%. The reason? Mr. Trump’s 2017 tax law changes generated a temporary economic spurt that is now fading. 

To understand this slowdown, consider S&P 500 corporate earnings. They grew faster than 20% through most of 2018 because Congress slashed the corporate tax rate by 14 percentage points, from 35% to 21%. But today – without additional tax cuts in place – earnings growth is rapidly slowing. In fact, S&P 500 profits probably grew less than 1% in 2019. Importantly, the same holds true for the broader economy: without the benefit of another USD 1.5 trillion tax package, economic growth has naturally started to slow.

The trade war is also pressuring the economy

Another reason the US economy may be slowing is the ongoing trade war between the US and other nations – particularly China. Mr. Trump is using tariffs and other measures to fix what he views as an unfair playing field. But this has created new problems – including retaliatory tariffs, reduced earnings for US multinationals, currency and commodity-market volatility, policy uncertainty and weaker business investment. The recently signed phase 1 US-China trade deal should dampen some of these pressures. But many of the toughest areas of disagreement have been deferred to a prospective phase 2 trade deal, which isn’t expected to get signed until after the US election—at the earliest. In the meantime, the bulk of tariffs remains in place.

While the world’s more cyclical, export-driven economies have been hard-hit since tariffs started ramping-up in early 2018, the US was insulated by the 2017 fiscal stimulus. Now, as the fiscal boost fades, trade war damage is washing-up on US shores. 

US-economy-in-lead-up-to-elections-HK-en-chart2

Could the trade war lead to recession? Maybe. Our proprietary models show a significant acceleration in medium-term risks – a development that appears associated with rising trade uncertainty (see chart above). 

Importantly, the threat of tariffs appears to be magnifying the downside risks. Although companies generally don’t like tariffs, they like uncertainty even less. When companies don’t know if policy could change materially in the short term, they have a tough time estimating the return on investment on long-range projects. If that translates into less business investment, then industrial production, manufacturing and hiring can also slow. These relationships mean that freezing or removing tariffs may not boost the outlook for growth as much as removing the threat of tariffs.

Nevertheless, the risk of recession has shrunk in recent months. And the economic slowdown that’s underway is partly the natural outcome from temporary fiscal stimulus – not a surprise or major concern. We’ve also seen spells of weakness previously: during the 2012 euro crisis and the 2015-2016 Chinese renminbi devaluations, the US economy got shakier but didn’t tip into recession. Keep in mind that the outlook for trade can change rapidly – perhaps even while you were reading this note. While that kind of uncertainty is one of the challenges facing the US economy as election season heats up, it also shows that risk has an upside as well as a downside.

Investment implications

  • Volatility should accelerate in 2020 as headlines around trade and the US elections spur risk-on / risk-off conditions.
  • Consider companies with strong balance sheets that could benefit from prospective economic re-acceleration while maintaining cash-flow if conditions slow further.
  • Look for diversification, including alternative strategies that don’t correlate with the broader market.
  • Recognise that the rise in recession risk has been material, but a downturn can be avoided – active management is increasingly important.

 

> download

Coronavirus spread forces investors to think again

09/03/2020
Coronavirus spread forces investors to think again

Summary

As the humanitarian costs of the coronavirus continue to rise, outbreaks beyond China are challenging the previous consensus view that the impact on markets could be relatively contained. Global stock markets are down, and negative sentiment may become a self-fulfilling prophecy, adding to the need for caution and an active approach.

Key takeaways

  • China has acted to bring the coronavirus under control, but global outbreaks will prolong uncertainty and stock markets across the world have been impacted
  • While the outbreak is impacting demand – both in China and globally – there will also be global supply implications, particularly for the automotive and technology sectors
  • We expect the dominant trend to be a “flight to safety” into the US dollar and US assets
  • This crisis underscores the vulnerable outlook for global risk assets following a strong end to 2019, but long-term investors will want to sit tight and monitor how events play out

Allianz Global Investors

You are leaving this website and being re-directed to the below website. This does not imply any approval or endorsement of the information by Allianz Global Investors Asia Pacific Limited contained in the redirected website nor does Allianz Global Investors Asia Pacific Limited accept any responsibility or liability in connection with this hyperlink and the information contained herein. Please keep in mind that the redirected website may contain funds and strategies not authorized for offering to the public in your jurisdiction. Besides, please also take note on the redirected website’s terms and conditions, privacy and security policies, or other legal information. By clicking “Continue”, you confirm you acknowledge the details mentioned above and would like to continue accessing the redirected website. Please click “Stay here” if you have any concerns.

Welcome to Allianz Global Investors

Select your language
  • 中文(繁體)
  • English
Select your role
  • Individual Investor
  • Intermediaries
  • Other Investors
  • Pension Investors
  • Allianz Global Investors Fund (“AGIF”)

    • Allianz Global Investors Fund (“AGIF”) as an umbrella fund under the UCITS regulations has within it different sub-funds investing in fixed income securities, equities, and derivative instruments, each with a different investment objective and/or risk profile.

    • All sub-funds (“Sub-Funds”) may invest in financial derivative instruments (“FDI”) which may expose to higher leverage, counterparty, liquidity, valuation, volatility, market and over the counter transaction risks. A Sub-Fund’s net derivative exposure may be up to 50% of its NAV. 

    • Some Sub-Funds as part of their investments may invest in any one or a combination of the instruments such as fixed income securities, emerging market securities, and/or mortgage-backed securities, asset-backed securities, property-backed securities (especially REITs) and/or structured products and/or FDI, exposing to various potential risks (including leverage, counterparty, liquidity, valuation, volatility, market, fluctuations in the value of and the rental income received in respect of the underlying property, and over the counter transaction risks). 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in single countries or industry sectors (in particular small/mid cap companies) which may reduce risk diversification. Some Sub-Funds are exposed to significant risks which include investment/general market, country and region, emerging market (such as Mainland China), creditworthiness/credit rating/downgrading, default, asset allocation, interest rate, volatility and liquidity, counterparty, sovereign debt, valuation, credit rating agency, company-specific, currency  (in particular RMB), RMB debt securities and Mainland China tax risks. 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in convertible bonds, high-yield, non-investment grade investments and unrated securities that may subject to higher risks (include volatility, loss of principal and interest, creditworthiness and downgrading, default, interest rate, general market and liquidity risks) and therefore may adversely impact the net asset value of the Sub-Funds. Convertibles will be exposed prepayment risk, equity movement and greater volatility than straight bond investments.

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest a significant portion of the assets in interest-bearing securities issued or guaranteed by a non-investment grade sovereign issuer (e.g. Philippines) and is subject to higher risks of liquidity, credit, concentration and default of the sovereign issuer as well as greater volatility and higher risk profile that may result in significant losses to the investors. 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in European countries. The economic and financial difficulties in Europe may get worse and adversely affect the Sub-Funds (such as increased volatility, liquidity and currency risks associated with investments in Europe).

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in the China A-Shares market, China B-Shares market and/or debt securities directly  via the Stock Connect or the China Interbank Bond Market or Bond Connect and or other foreign access regimes and/or other permitted means and/or indirectly through all eligible instruments the qualified foreign institutional investor program regime and thus is subject to the associated risks (including quota limitations, change in rule and regulations, repatriation of the Fund’s monies, trade restrictions, clearing and settlement, China market volatility and uncertainty, China market volatility and uncertainty, potential clearing and/or settlement difficulties and, change in economic, social and political policy in the PRC and taxation Mainland China tax risks).  Investing in RMB share classes is also exposed to RMB currency risks and adverse impact on the share classes due to currency depreciation.

    • Some Sub-Funds may adopt the following strategies, Sustainable and Responsible Investment Strategy, SDG-Aligned Strategy, Sustainability Key Performance Indicator Strategy (Relative), Green Bond Strategy, Multi Asset Sustainable Strategy, Sustainability Key Performance Indicator Strategy (Absolute Threshold), Environment, Social and Governance (“ESG”) Score Strategy, and Sustainability Key Performance Indicator Strategy (Absolute). The Sub-Funds may be exposed to sustainable investment risks relating to the strategies (such as foregoing opportunities to buy certain securities when it might otherwise be advantageous to do so, selling securities when it might be disadvantageous to do so, and/or relying on information and data from third party ESG research data providers and internal analyses which may be subjective, incomplete, inaccurate or unavailable and/or reducing risk diversifications compared to broadly based funds) which may result in the Sub-Fund being more volatile and have adverse impact on the performance of the Sub-Fund and consequently adversely affect an investor’s investment in the Sub-Fund. Also, some Sub-Funds may be particularly focusing on the GHG efficiency of the investee companies rather than their financial performance which may have an adverse impact on the Fund’s performance.

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in share class with fixed distribution percentage (Class AMf). Investors should note that fixed distribution percentage is not guaranteed. The share class is not an alternative to fixed interest paying investment. The percentage of distributions paid by these share classes is unrelated to expected or past income or returns of these share classes or the Sub-Funds. Distribution will continue even the Sub-Fund has negative returns and may adversely impact the net asset value of the Sub-Fund.  Positive distribution yield does not imply positive return.

    • Investment involves risks that could result in loss of part or entire amount of investors’ investment.

    • In making investment decisions, investors should not rely solely on this [website/material].

    Note: Dividend payments may, at the sole discretion of the Investment Manager, be made out of the Sub-Fund’s capital or effectively out of the Sub-Fund’s capital which represents a return or withdrawal of part of the amount investors originally invested and/or capital gains attributable to the original investment. This may result in an immediate decrease in the NAV per share and the capital of the Sub-Fund available for investment in the future and capital growth may be reduced, in particular for hedged share classes for which the distribution amount and NAV of any hedged share classes (HSC) may be adversely affected by differences in the interests rates of the reference currency of the HSC and the base currency of the respective Sub-Fund. Dividend payments are applicable for Class A/AM/AMg/AMi/AMgi/AQ Dis (Annually/Monthly/Quarterly distribution) and for reference only but not guaranteed.  Positive distribution yield does not imply positive return. For details, please refer to the Sub-Fund’s distribution policy disclosed in the offering documents.


    Allianz Global Investors Asia Fund

    • Allianz Global Investors Asia Fund (the “Trust”) is an umbrella unit trust constituted under the laws of Hong Kong pursuant to the Trust Deed. Allianz Thematic Income and Allianz Selection Income and Growth and Allianz Yield Plus Fund are the sub-funds of the Trust (each a “Sub-Fund”) investing in fixed income securities, equities and derivative instrument, each with a different investment objective and/or risk profile.

    • Some Sub-Funds are exposed to significant risks which include investment/general market, company-specific, emerging market, creditworthiness/credit rating/downgrading, default, volatility and liquidity, valuation, sovereign debt, thematic concentration, thematic-based investment strategy, counterparty, interest rate changes, country and region, asset allocation risks and currency (such as exchange controls, in particular RMB), and the adverse impact on RMB share classes due to currency depreciation.  

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in other underlying collective schemes and exchange traded funds. Investing in exchange traded funds may expose to additional risks such as passive investment, tracking error, underlying index, trading and termination. While investing in other underlying collective schemes (“CIS”) may subject to the risks associated to such CIS. 

    • Some Sub-Funds may invest in high-yield (non-investment grade and unrated) investments and/or convertible bonds which may subject to higher risks, such as volatility, creditworthiness, default, interest rate changes, general market and liquidity risks and therefore may  adversely impact the net asset value of the Fund. Convertibles may also expose to risks such as prepayment, equity movement, and greater volatility than straight bond investments.

    • All Sub-Funds may invest in financial derivative instruments (“FDI”) which may expose to higher leverage, counterparty, liquidity, valuation, volatility, market and over the counter transaction risks.  The use of derivatives may result in losses to the Sub-Funds which are greater than the amount originally invested. A Sub-Fund’s net derivative exposure may be up to 50% of its NAV.

    • These investments may involve risks that could result in loss of part or entire amount of investors’ investment.

    • In making investment decisions, investors should not rely solely on this website.

    Note: Dividend payments may, at the sole discretion of the Investment Manager, be made out of the Sub-Fund’s income and/or capital which in the latter case represents a return or withdrawal of part of the amount investors originally invested and/or capital gains attributable to the original investment. This may result in an immediate decrease in the NAV per distribution unit and the capital of the Sub-Fund available for investment in the future and capital growth may be reduced, in particular for hedged share classes for which the distribution amount and NAV of any hedged share classes (HSC) may be adversely affected by differences in the interests rates of the reference currency of the HSC and the base currency of the Sub-Fund. Dividend payments are applicable for Class A/AM/AMg/AMi/AMgi Dis (Annually/Monthly distribution) and for reference only but not guaranteed.  Positive distribution yield does not imply positive return. For details, please refer to the Sub-Fund’s distribution policy disclosed in the offering documents.

     

Please indicate you have read and understood the Important Notice.